Why is the Minecraft Combat Update and the new versions of some of them behaving like this?

Sp
11

(Troll contributions are reported)

Why are there some people who say, 'Nah… I prefer to play in the 1.8' 'And what have so many people against the cooldown that has existed since the 1.9? Well… Relative to the multiplayer, the cooldown is perhaps not so well suited. But for PvE, the cooldown and the shield are perfect… Are not they? Especially Notch is quite upset about the new releases, but why…

Maybe you are someone who prefers the old versions. Or maybe you know someone who does not like the new versions, and how does he argue?

In case you do not like the new versions, please argue.

(Blunt assertions do not count as arguments)

Schonmal thank you in advance to all who argue rationally and write no nonsense.

Mo

Because combos are no longer possible.

Sn

The cooldown came unexpectedly. I like him a lot now, also in the PVP. However, it is often the case that new things are rejected purely on principle. Too bad that the whole server did not just bring the Combat Update to their servers and stayed on the 1.8. Has given away a lot of potential.

ca

There was a very good video, but I can hardly decide; Much has come in the new versions, much of it I like very much and would not give it away. But MInecraft is not a real survival game anymore, where it's mostly about-as the name implies-mines and crafting, survival is (by default) almost too easy, so the game gets boring (now some may say "play dork hardcore", but that too is not very satisfying for me)

I hope I could bring you a bit closer to my arguments:-)

Bu

I personally also prefer 1.8. Yes, the cooldown annoys me too. Especially if you were used to being able to just hit it and have to get used to the fact that this is no longer possible. What is also a pity is that the block with the sword. Although this was replaced by a shield in Multiplayer PVP play, I found it a good way to communicate with other players in a certain way. And in the singleplayer, if you do not have a shield at the moment, you can no longer block yourself by blocking it with a sword, for example. Protect explosions.

Al

The combat is too lazy for me. It feels like dark souls where you have to plan every stroke exactly when to attack and when to block. I like minecraft especially because of the combos in the pvp. Unfortunately, these fall off 1.9 so I hate the newer versions.

Sp

@ NeleK48 In the beginning I also found the cooldown annoying, but now I think it's good that you can't killing monsters with spam clicking. If you have a diamond sword in the 1.8, you can kill monsters so fast that you have no chance to attack one. (My opinion)

The fact that the signs are broken annoys me already. (Is in the new 1.15 snapshots but no longer the case) I'm annoyed synonymous that you do not have a sign right at the beginning, but everything else would be just illogical anyway. But as soon as you have a shield, it can fight but go, which makes the shield in my opinion, even more fun than with the sword block function. And if you want to communicate with the block function of the sword in multiplayer with other players, then you simply switch to 1.8.

Of course I can understand that playing in the 1.8 without cooldown is more fun, but after a few weeks of gambling you should already have gotten used to it.

What do you think of the new versions apart from the new combat system? How do you like the new mobs, items and textures?

Bu

I do not like the new textures that much, I found the old ones more beautiful. However, the new mobs and items are mostly pretty cool, although sometimes I find new blocks a bit pointless or they just overwhelm me. Sometimes I find that some new stuff is just "too much" (unfortunately I can't think of a concrete example) but on the whole the new ideas of the last versions are quite cool.

Sp

@ NeleK48 I have to honestly admit that I like the new textures more. I do not know either… Especially the old Gravel-Texture is not that nice… Or the old swords-textures I think compared to the new somehow pretty detail arm and too oldschool. Sure, Minecraft should actually look old school, but still I like the modern pixel style very much. Most new textures are also a bit softer than the new ones. For the most part, the old textures look a little too coarse. Of course, I can still understand you that you like the old textures more.

Bu

There are some textures that have really improved, including Gravel's. The swords are also better now. But e.g. I used to like the cacti better.

Sp

@ picasso22 Yeah, some people just think of the new stuff as bad… Just because they're new. But I also have to say that some blocks from the 1.14 somehow do not fit so well in Minecraft. The bees that were added in the snapshot 19w34a, however, I find, however, very suitable for Minecraft.

Sp

@ NeleK48 I also somehow do not like the new wheat texture.

https://unlimitedworld.de/attachments/19w03a-png.32205/